Beneficiary Designations: Family Feuding About Benefits

Thousands of plan sponsors surveyed … the top two answers are on the board. Name two sensitive subjects you would prefer to avoid getting stuck in the middle of with your employees. Ready, go!

Death of a family member!

Getting a divorce!

Both correct! And, unfortunately, both are subjects that are likely to come up at some point in the life of a qualified retirement plan, often at the same time. We often read about the rules that are designed to protect participants, but those rules also extend to beneficiaries, spouses and former spouses. As much as we would probably all prefer to stay out of those discussions, understanding the basics can help you cool down potentially heated conversations.

Death and Taxes

As the saying goes, both are inevitable. In this case, the death of a participant could potentially lead to taxes depending on who the beneficiary is and what he or she elects to do with the inherited account. All of those tax ramifications could fill volumes, so we won’t go down that rabbit hole here. Instead, let’s focus on determining who the correct beneficiary is.

You may be thinking, “What is there to discuss? You look at the beneficiary designation form and pay the benefits to the person listed.” If you actually have those designations on file, it might be that easy, but things don’t always work out that way. In fact, there are cases litigated every year on this issue, some even going as far as the U.S. Supreme Court.

Perhaps an easy place to start is some documents that are not relevant in determining the correct beneficiary. It often comes as a surprise to many people to learn that many estate planning documents such as wills and prenuptial agreements are disregarded in determining who is entitled to the retirement plan accounts of a deceased plan participant. Without getting into the gory details, the gist is that those documents are governed by state law and deal with the disposition of an individual’s estate and non-plan assets. Company sponsored retirement plans are governed by federal law and follow their own set of rules. So, if a family member, attorney or some other party comes to you with a will or pre-nup, claiming it entitles someone to your former employee’s retirement benefits, the situation most definitely calls for further research.

Turning our attention to what is relevant, a properly completed beneficiary designation is first and foremost. But what is proper? For starters, the form should clearly identify the participant and plan as well as the person or persons who are the intended beneficiaries. These could be specific names – 100% to Richard Lawson - or may be more general - all of my children in equal shares. Both would be acceptable; however, something as general as “all of my family members” probably wouldn’t. In general, the more specific a participant is on the form, the more likely it is the account will find its way to the intended recipient and the easier it is for you to figure that out. Another critical piece of information is the participant’s signature and date. Since participants can change beneficiaries as often as they want, having that date is necessary to know which designation is the most current and should, therefore, be honored. 

The Newlywed Game and Beyond

The retirement plan rules specify that for a married participant, the default beneficiary is his or her spouse. It is possible to name someone else; however, the spouse must sign-off (with a notary) on the change. With recent court rulings recognizing same-gender marriages, participants who might not have been considered legally married in the past, now are. Since not all those in LGBT relationships are comfortable making it known, it is increasingly important for plan sponsors to be aware of these rules and seek appropriate means to obtain this information.

Another impact of the spousal default is that a participant’s subsequent marriage trumps any previous beneficiary designations even if the new spouse was involved in the previous decision. The reason is that the spouse was not a spouse at the time he or she agreed to it, so it doesn’t qualify as spousal consent. In that case, the simple solution is to have the participant complete a new designation form and have the new spouse consent.

Back To The Dating Game

Just because a spouse is the default beneficiary doesn’t mean it evaporates when a marriage ends. Although some plan documents now include language automatically revoking a spousal designation upon divorce, it is not the case across the board. As a result, it is highly recommended that participants complete new designations if they go through a divorce. With emotions running high, you might not want to get in the middle of it, but doing so now can prevent monumental headaches down the road if a former spouse makes a claim. And it happens…we see cases every year when a participant gave half of his or her account to a former spouse at the time of divorce with a Qualified Domestic Relations Order, forgot to change a beneficiary designation and ended up giving the rest of the account to the now-ex-spouse on death, much to the chagrin of the rest of the family. Just imagine how dicey it could get in the case of multiple marriages and divorces. 

One Strike And You’re Out

This is a pretty big deal, because paying benefits to the wrong person often results in the company having to come up with the funds to pay the correct person. Yikes!

So what happens if there is no designation on file? The first place to look is the plan document. Most list a default order to be used, and it usually looks something like this:

  • Spouse (if married); then
  • Children in equal shares; then
  • Parents in equal share; then
  • The participant’s estate.

If you are still in doubt (or even if you just want confirmation), it is a good idea to seek professional help. Contact your consultant at DWC or maybe your attorney. If there is still nothing definitive, it may be possible to file what is called an interpleader action with the court to get a judge to make the final determination. Even if it is later found to be incorrect, the company and the plan are insulated for having gone through that formal process.

Conclusion

All of this leads to one central recommendation … if you don’t have current beneficiary designations on file and where you can readily access them, consider updating your files. Some go so far as to send employee memos every year reminding them to update their designation if they’ve had a change in their lives, which may include marriage, birth of a child or divorce. That can also be a great time to remind employees of the impact of changes regarding same-gender marriage in a non-threatening way.

Having tight internal controls around this process can bring cooler heads to an emotionally heated situation and hopefully keep family feuds out of your office.

Contact DWC

The views expressed in this blog are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of any other person or organization. All content is provided for informational purposes only and is not intended to be tax or legal advice.