Plan sponsors have the option to allow participants to access their accounts while still employed via a plan loan or an in-service distribution. However, some companies prefer to limit that access so that accounts remain in the retirement plan to be used as intended—at retirement. A hardship distribution can be a compromise between the two, allowing participants access to their accounts only in times of financial hardship.
What is a hardship withdrawal?
The hardship withdrawal provision is an optional feature that can be included in a retirement plan to allow participants to access all or a portion of their account to satisfy an “immediate and heavy financial need.” There are several criteria that are used to determine whether the financial hardship is sufficient to qualify for a withdrawal using this feature.
You said it is an optional provision. Does that mean we can allow hardship withdrawals “on the fly”?
No. In order for a plan to grant hardship distributions, the plan document must specifically include the feature and spell out the parameters that apply.
What types of situations qualify for a hardship distribution?
The regulations have two different standards that can be applied – the safe harbor standard and the non-safe-harbor standard. Due to the extremely subjective nature of the words "financial hardship" many plans apply the safe harbor standard since it spells out the situations that qualify.
There are six of them. They are payment of …
- Expenses for a medical care that is tax-deductible (under Tax Code section 213(d)) to the individual and is not reimbursable by insurance.
Usually medical expenses must exceed a certain percentage of a person’s income before they are deductible; however, that percentage requirement is ignored for this purpose. Also, medical expenses incurred by a participant’s spouse and dependents qualify as a financial hardship.
It is important to note that if the expense is subject to reimbursement by an insurance company at a later date, it does not qualify as a hardship even if the participant is required to make payment up front and await reimbursement.
- Costs related to the purchase of a principal residence.
This must be the participant’s primary home; it cannot be a vacation home. The hardship withdrawal is not restricted to the purchase price and can include other items that are directly tied to the transaction such as closing costs. In addition, if a participant will immediately build a house, a hardship withdrawal can be taken for the purchase of the land on which the house will be built.
- Expenses for up to 12 months of post-secondary education.
This includes tuition, related educational fees, and room and board for the participant, spouse, and/or other dependent.
- Amounts necessary to prevent eviction or foreclosure from a principal residence.
Generally speaking, the participant must have received notice of a pending eviction or foreclosure in order to qualify under this criterion. Simply being a week behind on rent or wanting to avoid a late payment fee from the mortgage company is not sufficient.
- Burial or funeral expenses for the participant’s deceased parents, spouse, children, and/or dependents.
- Expenses for the repair of damage to the participant’s principal residence that are tax-deductible to the participant (under Tax Code section 165) as a casualty loss.
These expenses are similar to medical expenses in a couple of ways. One is the income percentage for tax-deductibility is ignored, and the other is that expenses subject to reimbursement by insurance do not qualify.
It is also important to note that the expenses must be due to casualty loss. For example, if a participant must replace his or her roof because a tree fell on it during a storm, that is a casualty loss and would potentially qualify. On the other hand, if the roof has to be replaced simply because it’s old and worn out, that would not qualify.
A plan can, but is not required to, expand the definition of hardship to include any of the above situations that are incurred by a participant’s designated primary beneficiary.
Now that we have covered the reasons, how is the amount determined?
The maximum amount of the hardship distribution is basically the actual amount of the applicable expense minus whatever amounts a participant can access from sources outside the plan. That means a participant is generally required to first exhaust any savings accounts, outside investment accounts, credit card cash advances, loans, etc. that are available to him or her. This includes taking a loan from the retirement plan to the extent loans are permitted. Any qualified expenses that remain are eligible for hardship.
Obviously, a participant cannot withdraw more than he or she has available in the plan. We will touch on that in a little more detail later in this FAQ.
What happens if using up all of those other resources only makes the financial hardship worse?
There is an exception for this type of situation, but it should be applied with caution. One of the most clear-cut examples where this would come into play is with the purchase of a primary residence. Draining all savings and maxing out cash advances from credit cards would likely cause the mortgage company to reconsider. As a result, the participant would only be required to use other resources to the extent it would not jeopardize his or her ability to obtain the mortgage.
If using other resources is just inconvenient or carries a fee, that is not enough to get out of it.
Are hardship distributions subject to individual income tax?
Yes, the participant must claim the hardship distribution amount as income on his or her individual tax return. In addition, the amount of the withdrawal is subject to an early withdrawal penalty equal to 10% if the participant is under the age of 59 ½.
Hardship withdrawals are not eligible to be rolled over to an IRA or other plan, so they are subject to a voluntary tax withholding at the time of distribution. The default withholding rate is 10%, but the participant can elect to increase or decrease it, or waive it altogether.
It seems like the tax ramifications might add to the hardship. Can a participant increase the amount of the distribution to cover the expected tax burden?
Yes, any reasonably anticipated federal, state, or local tax that will be payable by the participant as a result of the hardship withdrawal can be added to the amount request. In addition, the participant can add any distribution fees that might be charged by the plan’s recordkeeper keeper or other service provider for processing the request.
Who verifies all of this? I don’t really want to get involved in all of those personal details for my participants.
There are two elements of a hardship distribution – the reason and the amount. Plan sponsors do have an obligation to obtain documentation that supports the reason for the request. More on that later.
As for the amount, there are also two elements to be considered. One is the “principal” amount of the request and the other is the ancillary stuff (taxes, fees, other resources, etc.). Plan sponsors should obtain some basic documentation that supports the principal amount requested; however, they can rely on statements from the participant on the amount needed to gross-up for taxes and fees as well as the availability (or lack, thereof) of outside resources.
In other words, sponsors to do not have to undertake a financial investigation of the participant. There is one important exception. If the sponsor knows (or reasonably should know) that a participant is being less than completely truthful about his or her financial situation, the sponsor cannot turn a blind eye and should request more documentation. An example of this might be a request to cover medical expenses that the sponsor knows are covered by the company-provided medical plan.
What sort of documentation is required to substantiate the reason and principal amount?
Back in 2015, the IRS provided informal guidance indicating that plan sponsors are required to obtain and keep the following items to document hardship distributions:
- Documentation of the hardship request, review, and approval.
- Financial information and documentation that substantiates the employee’s immediate and heavy financial need.
- Documentation to support that the hardship distribution was properly made according to applicable plan provisions and the Internal Revenue Code.
- Proof of the actual distribution made and related Forms 1099-R.
That guidance indicated that either paper or electronic format is acceptable but that it is not enough for participants to self-certify.
Then, in 2017, the IRS issued additional guidance in the form of a memo to plan auditors that seems to allow a summary certification process. In order to use the summary certification, plan sponsors must provide a notice to participants requesting hardship distributions with basic information about the hardship rules, and the participant must agree to “preserve source documents and to make them available at any time, upon request, to the employer or administrator.”
The attachment to the IRS memo then includes a bullet-point list of the summary information the sponsor must collect based on the type of hardship distribution being requested.
Unfortunately, the memo does not provide much insight as to whether the IRS thinks the summary certification is sufficient if a participant does not follow through with his or her agreement to provide the source documents on request. As such, it is unclear whether this summary approach is viable from a practical standpoint.
Are there any limits on which plan accounts are available for hardship distribution?
Yes. There are some outside legal limits that apply; however, each plan sponsor can further restrict availability as it deems appropriate.
The rules specifically prohibit employees from taking hardship withdrawals from accounts holding safe harbor contributions, qualified matching contributions, and qualified nonelective contributions unless the participant is at least age 59 ½. In addition, any investment gains on 401(k) deferrals made after 1988 are not available – the deferral basis (the amount actually contributed) is available, just not any investment gains on those amounts.
Other than that, a plan can permit hardship withdrawals from any contribution source in the plan, but it is not uncommon for sponsors to limit hardships only to deferral accounts and/or other accounts in which the participant is fully vested.
Can a participant keep making/receiving plan contributions after taking a hardship withdrawal?
A participant does not cease participation after taking a hardship withdrawal, so he or she continues to be eligible for company contributions as usual based on the terms of the plan. However, plan sponsors have an obligation to suspend 401(k) deferrals for the participant for a period of six months immediately following the date the hardship distribution is made.
It is important to work with your payroll provider and/or recordkeeper keeper to ensure deferrals are stopped.
What happens at the end of the six-month suspension period?
To answer this question, it is first important to point out something sounds like just a semantic point. The hardship rules require deferrals to be suspended for 6 months, not discontinued. That is important because a suspension suggests a temporary modification.
That is all a long way of saying that unless either the participant chooses to completely stop deferring or the plan document/distribution form provides for a deemed change to 0% when taking a hardship, it is the plan sponsors responsibility to resume the withholding of deferrals at the pre-hardship rate when the 6-month suspension period expires.